Christ / Church / SBC / June 14, 2007

Debate on Speaking in Tongues

The audio is available for Dr. Russell Moore’s debate with Dwight McKissic on the Jerry Johnson Live radio show. The debate is well done and well-spirited. Three deficiencies are clear in McKissic’s views on the issue:

  1. He prooftexts 1 Cor. 14:2, with no consideration for its context, as the primary support for his view in the same way a Jehovah’s Witness prooftexts Col. 1:15 to deny the deity of Christ. One verse in isolation from its context cannot be foundational to an argument.
  2. He resists any interaction with historical perspectives on the issue in an effort to just stick to his prooftext.
  3. He engages in what I have dubbed ‘charismatic fundamentalism.’ In fact, he goes as far as to say that anyone who does not share his view on this issue is not an inerrantist. Wow!

Private prayer languages are not a modern day manifestation of the biblical gift of tongues. There are several reasons this is true:

  • The biblical gift of tongues is prophetic in nature–it was for the purpose of inspired revelation. Once God provided a written body of inspired literature to the early church, this oral transmission phased out.
  • The biblical gift of tongues, like all other spiritual gifts, is for the building up of the body of Christ; not for the building up of individual Christians.
  • The biblical gift of tongues marked the initial advance of the gospel to Jerusalem, Judea/Samaria and the ends of the earth.
  • The biblical gift of tongues occurred in known languages in contrast to much of what goes on today in ‘ecstatic’ speech.

The bottom line is that, since the purpose of tongues (as a form of prophetic revelation of divine inspiration) has now been fulfilled, the spiritual gift of tongues has now been fulfilled. While it may be possible for a believer to practice something they consider a private prayer language, this is not the biblical gift of tongues. We must not call it what it isn’t, and we must recognize the potential danger of it.

Bookmark and Share

Previous Post
Raising the Roof on the Glass Ceiling?
Next Post
Things I Like About Texas


Jun 15, 2007

[…] ===================== *** Phillip Bethancourt spells out the debate on speaking in tongues in this post, taken from a dialogue between Dr. Russell Moore and Dwight McKissic. Agree or not, it brings some clarity to the argument. ===================== *** Tom Ascol wraps up the good, the bad, and the confusing in this post on this year’s annual Southern Baptist Convention that was held in San Antonio, Tx. Be sure and check out Tom’s other blog posts from the rest of the convention. ===================== *** Tim Challies asks some good questions about becoming Reformed in this post, dealing with the rise in interest in the Doctrines of Grace. ===================== *** Dan Phillips lists 25 personal reflections on life, love, and everything in between in this post from the Pyromaniac’s blog. As a young’un myself, I was deeply thankful and appreciative for Dan sharing what the Lord has shown him through 51 years of life. ===================== *** Justin Taylor links to Dr. Russell Moore’s testimony given on Capital Hill, in which he gives ‘the’ Southern Baptist opinion on Global Warming. I read the entire testimony. It was quite thorough, and informative and definitely worth a look-see. ===================== *** This radio show is awesome: Law and Gospel. For the first couple of weeks of June, the host Rev. Tom Baker, goes through the parables of the NT. Find your head phones and be blessed. ===================== *** I discovered 75 cents for a book! It’s amazing! Granted, that you pay $3-$4 for shipping and handling, but still! ===================== […]

Jun 22, 2007

Just wondering when you were going to get back to work and post another blog… waiting patiently


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

More Story
Raising the Roof on the Glass Ceiling?
Just in time for next week's Southern Baptist Convention, Dr. Albert Mohler has resumed writing on his blog, Conventional...